Skip to site navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer content Skip to Site Search page Skip to People Search page

Bylined Articles

EEOC Retreats From Alleging 'Systemic' Discrimination, Brings Fewer Cases Overall

By Chris O'Malley
October 29, 2025
Corporate Counsel

EEOC Retreats From Alleging 'Systemic' Discrimination, Brings Fewer Cases Overall

By Chris O'Malley
October 29, 2025
Corporate Counsel

Read below

"The filing of systemic actions really has been downplayed and is not the main focus or emphasis by the EEOC anymore," said Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., a Duane Morris partner.

Lawsuits filed by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission dropped by 15% in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, with the agency likely to continue to focus less on systemic cases on behalf of a big group of workers in an industry, profession or company.

That's a preliminary take from Duane Morris based on the law firm's tracking of EEOC litigation for the 2025 fiscal year, which included the first nine months of the second Trump administration.

The EEOC filed 94 lawsuits in fiscal 2025 compared with 111 in 2024 and 143 in fiscal 2023, the law firm said. (See graphic below story for an in-depth breakdown of the data.)

That's still significantly lower than the pre-pandemic high of 217 in fiscal 2018, during the first term of President Donald Trump.

"The decline in enforcement activity suggests that during President Trump's second term in office, employers should not expect the EEOC to be as aggressive as past regimes in terms of the volume of government enforcement lawsuits, particularly in terms of systemic litigation," Duane Morris partner Gerald Maatman Jr. said last month in his preliminary analysis of EEOC data.

At that time, Maatman said the 2025 EEOC data "should be taken with a grain of salt," given the fiscal year was a time of transition in administrations.

But during a webinar last week, Maatman and his employment law team offered some additional observations that could indicate things to come.

In 2025, 14 of the EEOC 94 lawsuits—or 15%—were of the systemic variety, about the same as the previous year.

In EEOC-speak, systemic cases are those with "a pattern or practice, policy and/or class cases where the discrimination has a broad impact on an industry, profession, company or geographic location."

"If we were talking about 10 years ago, over 50% of these cases would be on behalf of groups of employees, called systemic cases. Now, nearly 80% of the filings are what are called 'onesies' or 'twosies' on behalf of one or two employees—very targeted at either small employers or very large employers," Maatman said.

Often, these cases allege retaliation or discrimination based on disability more than anything else.

"Why? Because those are the two causes of action probably most impervious to a motion for summary judgment and those are the theories that EEOC typically has had the most success on in litigation."

Two years ago, the EEOC sought to "get the most bang for its buck" by bringing large cases, Maatman said. It invested in training of staff on identifying and investigating systemic discrimination.

"Systemic actions ... would send a message to an industry and would impact the greatest number of people," he added.

Under the Trump administration, that's been scrapped, he said.

"The filing of systemic actions really has been downplayed and is not the main focus or emphasis by the EEOC anymore."

There were some exceptions. Duane Morris partner Jennifer Riley noted the EEOC's $850,000 settlement in July with the Venetian Resort Las Vegas for alleged religious discrimination against employees.

Maatman said he used to get a call once a week from general counsel about systemic investigations in which they were involved. Not so much anymore.

He noted that the EEOC in September indicated it would no longer bring lawsuits solely on allegations of disparate impact. It's a form of discrimination in which a policy or practice, though apparently neutral, has a disproportionate effect on a protected class of individuals.

Many systemic cases invoke disparate impact or adverse impact theory.

"The fact that the EEOC is abandoning and peeling back its use of that tool is one signal that, to the extent they're going to be systemic cases, there are going to be less of them," Maatman added.

The EEOC's stepping back from bringing cases based solely on disparate impact could have an effect on employment discrimination issues involving artificial intelligence, leaving employees to pursue private litigation.

Riley pointed to a case filed earlier this year in the Northern District of California by job seeker Derek Mobley against HR software giant Workday.

Mobley, a Black man over the age of 40 who claims he suffers from anxiety and depression, alleges that despite his experience and degree in finance, Workday's AI-powered screening tool caused him to be rejected for at least 100 jobs due to race, disability and age.

Workday has denied that its technology is discriminatory.

The EEOC's move away from using disparate impact theory in enforcement "almost certainly will reduce government-led investigations into algorithmic discrimination based on disparate impact theory for the foreseeable future, at least," Riley said.

Disability and gender discrimination, and those related to retaliation, continued to be the leading causes of action in EEOC cases in fiscal 2025, the law firm found.

However, "you'll see there are no filings with respect to gender identity or sexual orientation," Maatman said.

"That is the hand of the Trump administration de-emphasizing that particular cause of action that first arose during the Obama and Biden administrations, where EEOC was an active filer in that particular space."

In February, citing the administration's executive order on "gender ideology extremism," the EEOC announced it would withdraw seven lawsuits it had filed on that issue.

Cases brought under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act once again comprised the majority of cases filed in fiscal 2025—about 50%, versus 58% of filings in the previous year, Riley said.

That was followed by EEOC filings in Americans with Disabilities Act cases—32% of all cases vs. 42% in 2024.

There was an uptick in filings invoking the Age Discrimination in Employment Act—nine vs. six in fiscal 2024—and in the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act—six compared with three in fiscal 2023. Because the law went into effect in June 2023, it was in place for only the final three months of that year.

Notably absent were cases filed under the Equal Pay Act or Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act, which had been priorities under the previous administration, Riley said.

As in the previous fiscal year, the hospitality and health care industries bore the brunt of EEOC lawsuits. But there was a big decrease in enforcement actions against retailers, from 23% in fiscal 2024 to 11% of cases in 2025.

Reprinted with permission from Corporate Counsel, © ALM Media Properties LLC. All rights reserved.