The Trump administration on June 30 offered U.S. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan, who is overseeing the case, a panoply of reasons why it believes the case should be dismissed. It said Trump "acted within his statutory and constitutional authority" when he removed Samuels after she and other Democratic commissioners publicly spoke out against executive orders. Even if Title VII did contain removal protections for commissioners, the federal government said it would violate Article II of the U.S. Constitution.
Samuels' brief opposing the federal government's dismissal motion is due July 28.
Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., a partner at Duane Morris LLP, said the case is a fascinating one that poses big questions for the agency both in the short term and the long term.
"The stakes are high, and the issues are novel," Maatman said. "Title VII does not directly address the circumstances in which a president can displace EEOC commissioners before the end of their five-year terms. Trump deviated from past practice where the commissioners functioned with a five-person quorum with three of one party and two of the other."
By removing Samuels and Burrows, Trump "derailed the ability of the EEOC to roll out enforcement guidance" and removed Democratic commissioners who weren't aligned with his views regarding the agency's priorities, according to Maatman.
To read the full text of this article, please visit Law360 (subscription required).


