Two contentious plan management issues that have tormented the DC industry — class action certification and arbitration — are packed into a single case now before the Supreme Court which, ERISA attorneys say, has the opportunity to provide uniform legal guidance and address a contested area of retirement law.
A pro-sponsor ruling in The Capital Group Companies Inc. et al. vs. Cathy Pover on either or both issues could provide significant financial relief to DC sponsors. It could weaken a plaintiff’s ability to file a class action lawsuit on behalf of hundreds or thousands of participants, and it could strengthen sponsors’ use of individual arbitration rulings in ERISA violations instead of class action lawsuits, DC experts said.
“ERISA is a very hot issue now,” said Gerald L. Maatman, Jr., a partner in the Duane Morris LLP law firm, which defends sponsors in ERISA cases. “Capital Group is the big 800-pound gorilla.”
The Capital Group case is in the early stage before the Supreme Court. Capital Group, which had $3.34 trillion in assets under management last year, petitioned the court in August 2026 after losing cases at the federal district court and federal appeals court levels. The justices recently asked Pover, a former Capital Group employee, to respond by Dec. 2.
The justices’ request indicates their interest in addressing the two prominent retirement industry issues, said Maatman, whose firm isn’t involved in the Capital Group case. “The stakes are very high,” said Maatman, who is chair of his firm’s class action defense team. “Arbitration law is running smack into ERISA.”
To read the full article, please visit the Pensions & Investments site (subscription required).


